Shiloh Season
by Phyllis Reynolds Naylor
Review by: Julia
Grade: 6
Age: 11

Becky was lost, Shiloh was blamed for not watching her. Then Marty found her. then Judd broke his leg by a car accident. They found out by Shiloh. They went to visit Judd and Shiloh came but he was scared. Then, Judd was going to pat Shiloh but Marty wasn't sure if he would hurt him. Shiloh was scared. Judd wanted to pat Shiloh but he was scared. I won't tell you what happens at the end.

I liked this book because they made it so realistic. The writer of the book made you scared so you would want to read more and more. I would give this book 3 stars.

Do you want to write a review? Click here or write to laura at

More reviews